Legion World Forums LEGION CLUBHOUSE The Legion of Super-Heroes Discussing the pre-Shooter Legion

Are you kidding me? Nobody should ever apologize for talking about the Legion :-) and I've really enjoyed your comments on various threads.

That was not unique to TNG but was typical of most all US television shows from the late 70's up until the last ten years or so. Standard actor contracts had changed from the golden age of TV to where all lead actors were required to be in almost every episode of a series. For example, this was not the situation for Star Trek original series as the contracts were different. There were many episodes without Uhura, Sulu, Chekov or Chapel but no explanation was given in story. It really annoyed me - especially in those episodes were the ship was in danger or what have you and you get a one-off character appearing instead of one of the regulars. Having all of the regulars appear (even if briefly) in each episode of TNG was something I especially welcomed. However I do you remember Majel Barrett Roddenberry being very vocal with TNG at the time in her dislike of the contractual requirements - for much the same reasons you mention with these early Legion stories. But with these early legion stories, I took it as a way for readers to get to see their favorite Legionnaires - if only briefly. As course Levitz would take this formula and run with it to huge success in his early 80's run.

Thanks for providing a broader perspective on this.


Personally, I thought that was more realistic. There would be many instances when the main crew members were on vacation, lecturing at the academy, or doing something else. The presence of other crew member created a sense of verisimilitude.


I totally get it. As a fan, I loved it when any of my favorite characters put in so much as a one-panel cameo. Since then, I've come to appreciate it when characters are only there when the story requires them to be there. Babylon 5 was masterful at this. Sometimes characters would appear briefly or not at all--but it all served the needs or the story instead of the story serving the characters. But to each his or her own.

This is the first I've heard about Majel's complaints. Was this in reference to her role as Lwaxana or as the computer voice?

"For example, this was not the situation for Star Trek original series as the contracts were different. There were many episodes without Uhura, Sulu, Chekov or Chapel but no explanation was given in story."

I'm current watching the 1st season of "VOYAGE TO THE BOTTOM OF THE SEA", which I have not seen since the late 1960s. (After that, the entire B&W season-- the one with the best writing-- was YANKED out of circulation, because IDIOT programmers thought audiences didn't want to watch B&W TV shows.)

Thsi week's episode (I'm watching one per week, just like when it was first run), I was surprised when both Kowalksi & Patterson were nowhere to be found! And those 2 guys are practically in every story.

I wouldn't call it Majel complaining as that's a whole other topic - this was more her sharing her opinion. And this was not in regards to her acting as Lwaxana or the computer voice, but in her role as being wife to the creator and head producer of TNG. It's been years
(decades?) so my memory is likely not accurate, but I believe she was responding to a fan question at a Q&A and explained that Gene would receive the scripts in varying degrees of completion to review (I think this was after his stroke and starting to wind down his
day-to-day involvement but maybe not). Majel and Gene would read them to together (shades of today's table reads) and Majel would give her feedback to Gene. And she made a point here of noting how often the story (plotting, pace, etc) would suffer due to the machinations
to get all of the actors on-screen (if only briefly) to meet contract requirements.

You mention instances where some main crew members would not be in a episode for various reasons. But on the original series, those reasons rarely made it on screen and more fans filling in the blanks over the years. Now TNG (and forward) was very good about explaining
on screen why someone else was barely in an episode or what have you without taking up a lot of screen time to do it.