 Previous Thread |
|
Next Thread 
|
|
 Re: Suicide Squad Idol?
|
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666
Wanderer
|
OP
Wanderer
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666 |
Round 3 Begins!
Important Info Below
All the zeros are eliminated this round. We are now going to move onto scale voting, due to the large number of characters with 6 votes. The scale will be by 5's, as that has worked well.
Guide to the Scale from my Experiences
5- Least Amount of Points
10-25: Lower amount of points
30-45: Mid-Range
50: Highest amount of points
Afterthought (New 52)
Amanda Waller
Amanda Waller (Arrow)
Amanda Waller (Film)
Amanda Waller (Justice League Unlimited)
Amanda Waller (New 52)
Atom (Adam Cray)
Bane
Batman
Batman (Rebirth)
BattleAxe (New 52)
Behemoth (New 52)
Big Sir
Black Adam
Black Manta (New 52)
Black Orchid
Black Spider (Assault on Arkham)
Black Spider (New 52)
Blackguard
Blackstarr
Blockbuster (Mark Desmond)
Bolt
Briscoe
Bronze Tiger
Bronze Tiger (Arrow)
Bronze Tiger (Rebirth)
Cameron Chase
Capt. Richard Montgomery Flag
Captain Boomerang (Assault on Arkham)
Captain Boomerang (Film)
Captain Boomerang (George Harkness)
Captain Boomerang (Justice League Unlimited)
Captain Boomerang (New 52)
Captain Boomerang (Owen Mercer)
Captain Cold
Catalyst
Catwoman (Rebirth)
Cheetah (New 52)
Chemo
Chloe Sullivan (Smallville)
Chronos
Clock King
Clock King (Justice League Unlimited)
Cluemaster
Copperhead
Count Vertigo
Cupid (Arrow)
Deadshot
Deadshot (Arrow)
Deadshot (Assault on Arkham)
Deadshot (Film)
Deadshot (Justice League Unlimited)
Deadshot (New 52)
Deadshot (Smallville)
Digger Harkness (Arrow)
Doctor Light (Arthur Light)
Double Down
Dr. Hugh Evans
Dr. Moon
Dr. Polaris (New 52)
Duchess
El Diablo (Film)
El Diablo (New 52)
Electrocutioner
Eliza
Emerald Empress (Rebirth)
Enchantress
Enchantress (Film)
Enchantress (New 52)
Enforcer
Firehawk
Flex
Flo Crowly
Golden Eagle II
Hack (Rebirth)
Harley Quinn (Arrow)
Harley Quinn (Assault on Arkham)
Harley Quinn (Film)
Harley Quinn (New 52)
Heatmonger
Iceberg (New 52)
Icicle (Cameron Mahkent)
Icicle (Smallville)
Javelin
Jess Bright (Koshchei the Deathless)
Jewelee
Jewelee (Rebirth)
John Diggle (Arrow)
Johnny Sorrow (Rebirth)
Karin Grace
Karma (Wayne Hawkins)
Katana
Katana (Film)
Katana (New 52)
Killer Croc (Film)
Killer Croc (New 52)
Killer Frost
Killer Frost (Rebirth)
King Faraday
King Shark
King Shark (Arrow)
King Shark (Assault on Arkham)
King Shark (New 52)
Knockout
Lady Liberty
Larvanaut
Lobo (Rebirth)
Lyla Diggle /Harbinger(Arrow)
Major Disaster
Major Victory
Manchester Black
Manhunter/Privateer (Mark Shaw)
Marauder
Maser/ Air Wave III
Mindboggler
Mirror Master (Evan McCulloch)
Mr. 104
Multi-Man
Multiplex
Nemesis (Tom Tresser)
Nightshade
Oracle
Outlaw
Parasite
Penguin
Persuader (Cole Parker)
Plasmus
Plastique
Plastique (Justice League Unlimited)
Poison Ivy
Power Girl
Psi
Punch
Punch (Rebirth)
Putty
Quartzite
Ravan
Ravan Nassar (Arrow)
Raven (Arrow)
Reactron
Reverse-Flash (New 52 Daniel West)
Richard Rogers Flag (Anthony Miller)
Rick Flag (Film)
Rick Flag (Rebirth)
Rick Flag (Smallville)
Rick Flagg (Justice League Unlimited)
Rustam (Rebirth)
Sam Makoa
Savant (New 52)
Schrek
Sgt. Frank Rock
Shade the Changing Man
Sheba
Shrapnel
Shrapnel (Arrow)
Shrike
Sidearm
Silent Majority
Silver Swan (Valerie Beaudry)
Sledge
Slipknot
Slipknot (Film)
Solomon Grundy
Speedy (Roy Harper)
Sportsmaster (Victor Gover)
Stalnoivolk
Star-Spangled Kid (Courtney Whitmore)
Steel (John Henry Irons)
Superboy (Kon-El)
Tattooed Man
The General
Thermal
Thinker (Cliff Carmichael)
Thinker (Clifford De Voe)
Top
Torque (Arrow)
Twister
Unknown Soldier
Ventriloquist (Rebirth)
Virtuosa
Vixen
Volocity
Warp (Smallville)
Warrant
Weasel
White Dragon
Wildcat
Will Evans (New 52)
Windfall
Writer
Yasemin Soze
Last edited by Myg - Andy S; 02/09/17 01:04 AM.
|
|
|
Re: Suicide Squad Idol?
|
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,188
Legionnaire!
|
|
Legionnaire!
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,188 |
Umm, I don't think you eliminated anyone from that list. 
|
|
|
Re: Suicide Squad Idol?
|
Joined: Sep 2013
Posts: 31,847
Tempus Fugitive
|
|
Tempus Fugitive
Joined: Sep 2013
Posts: 31,847 |
Someone's dressing up the Silent Majority duplicates as the outgoing characters!
"...not having to believe in a thing to be interested in it and not having to explain a thing to appreciate the wonder of it."
|
|
|
Re: Suicide Squad Idol?
|
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 6,364
Wanderer
|
|
Wanderer
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 6,364 |
Calling Andy - I need to know exactly which New 52 characters to give 0 points to!
|
|
|
Re: Suicide Squad Idol?
|
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666
Wanderer
|
|
OP
Wanderer
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666 |
I'll check again
I've been sick all week
Agh
|
|
|
Re: Suicide Squad Idol?
|
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666
Wanderer
|
|
OP
Wanderer
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666 |
These are examples of learning curve on an idol ...
Ok I fixed the list
As for the scoring...
I've noticed that we go from 1/0 option to scaled options by around round 3 (because some people will still get 1 vote)
By the scaled option, we end up dumping people who don't get in the top 60% (or whatever line we make) of the vote. The lowest people can get in scaled voting is 5 due to outlier issues in the scoring
Is there another way to get at this?
|
|
|
Re: Suicide Squad Idol?
|
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666
Wanderer
|
|
OP
Wanderer
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666 |
Someone's dressing up the Silent Majority duplicates as the outgoing characters! A clever way to get around brain bombs
|
|
|
Re: Suicide Squad Idol?
|
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,188
Legionnaire!
|
|
Legionnaire!
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,188 |
Afterthought (New 52) 5
Amanda Waller 50
Amanda Waller (Arrow) 10
Amanda Waller (Film) 30
Amanda Waller (Justice League Unlimited) 40
Amanda Waller (New 52) 25
Atom (Adam Cray) 50
Bane 5
Batman 30
Batman (Rebirth) 20
BattleAxe (New 52) 5
Behemoth (New 52) 5
Big Sir 5
Black Adam 30
Black Manta (New 52) 5
Black Orchid 50
Black Spider (Assault on Arkham) 5
Black Spider (New 52) 5
Blackguard 5
Blackstarr 5
Blockbuster (Mark Desmond) 40
Bolt 25
Briscoe 50
Bronze Tiger 50
Bronze Tiger (Arrow) 5
Bronze Tiger (Rebirth) 30
Cameron Chase 10
Capt. Richard Montgomery Flag 40
Captain Boomerang (Assault on Arkham)5
Captain Boomerang (Film) 25
Captain Boomerang (George Harkness)50
Captain Boomerang (Justice League Unlimited)40
Captain Boomerang (New 52)35
Captain Boomerang (Owen Mercer)40
Captain Cold 50
Catalyst 40
Catwoman (Rebirth) 15
Cheetah (New 52) 5
Chemo 20
Chloe Sullivan (Smallville) 5
Chronos 45
Clock King 5
Clock King (Justice League Unlimited)15
Cluemaster 5
Copperhead 15
Count Vertigo 50
Cupid (Arrow) 5
Deadshot 50
Deadshot (Arrow) 35
Deadshot (Assault on Arkham)15
Deadshot (Film)15
Deadshot (Justice League Unlimited)40
Deadshot (New 52)35
Deadshot (Smallville) 5
Digger Harkness (Arrow) 20
Doctor Light (Arthur Light) 50
Double Down 5
Dr. Hugh Evans 45
Dr. Moon 35
Dr. Polaris (New 52) 15
Duchess 50
El Diablo (Film) 40
El Diablo (New 52) 35
Electrocutioner 5
Eliza 5
Emerald Empress (Rebirth) 20
Enchantress 50
Enchantress (Film) 25
Enchantress (New 52) 35
Enforcer 5
Firehawk 20
Flex 5
Flo Crowly 35
Golden Eagle II 5
Hack (Rebirth) 35
Harley Quinn (Arrow) 5
Harley Quinn (Assault on Arkham) 15
Harley Quinn (Film) 40
Harley Quinn (New 52) 40
Heatmonger 5
Iceberg (New 52) 5
Icicle (Cameron Mahkent) 15
Icicle (Smallville) 15
Javelin 45
Jess Bright (Koshchei the Deathless) 45
Jewelee 50
Jewelee (Rebirth) 25
John Diggle (Arrow) 20
Johnny Sorrow (Rebirth) 20
Karin Grace 45
Karma (Wayne Hawkins) 15
Katana 40
Katana (Film) 30
Katana (New 52) 35
Killer Croc (Film) 30
Killer Croc (New 52) 40
Killer Frost 15
Killer Frost (Rebirth) 15
King Faraday 20
King Shark 40
King Shark (Arrow) 35
King Shark (Assault on Arkham)15
King Shark (New 52) 40
Knockout 40
Lady Liberty 25
Larvanaut 5
Lobo (Rebirth) 5
Lyla Diggle /Harbinger(Arrow) 10
Major Disaster 5
Major Victory 45
Manchester Black 5
Manhunter/Privateer (Mark Shaw) 50
Marauder 5
Maser/ Air Wave III 40
Mindboggler 50
Mirror Master (Evan McCulloch) 40
Mr. 104 45
Multi-Man 5
Multiplex 40
Nemesis (Tom Tresser) 50
Nightshade 50
Oracle 50
Outlaw 50
Parasite 45
Penguin 45
Persuader (Cole Parker) 5
Plasmus 20
Plastique 45
Plastique (Justice League Unlimited) 35
Poison Ivy 50
Power Girl 20
Psi 45
Punch 50
Punch (Rebirth) 25
Putty 5
Quartzite 5
Ravan 50
Ravan Nassar (Arrow) 5
Raven (Arrow) 5
Reactron 5
Reverse-Flash (New 52 Daniel West) 5
Richard Rogers Flag (Anthony Miller) 50
Rick Flag (Film) 20
Rick Flag (Rebirth) 35
Rick Flag (Smallville) 5
Rick Flagg (Justice League Unlimited) 40
Rustam (Rebirth) 15
Sam Makoa 30
Savant (New 52) 5
Schrek 30
Sgt. Frank Rock 10
Shade the Changing Man 50
Sheba 50
Shrapnel 5
Shrapnel (Arrow) 5
Shrike 40
Sidearm 30
Silent Majority 20
Silver Swan (Valerie Beaudry) 35
Sledge 5
Slipknot 45
Slipknot (Film) 10
Solomon Grundy 15
Speedy (Roy Harper) 45
Sportsmaster (Victor Gover) 5
Stalnoivolk 45
Star-Spangled Kid (Courtney Whitmore) 5
Steel (John Henry Irons) 5
Superboy (Kon-El) 40
Tattooed Man 5
The General 40
Thermal 5
Thinker (Cliff Carmichael) 50
Thinker (Clifford De Voe) 45
Top 5
Torque (Arrow) 5
Twister 5
Unknown Soldier 5
Ventriloquist (Rebirth) 20
Virtuosa 20
Vixen 50
Volocity 5
Warp (Smallville) 5
Warrant 5
Weasel 40
White Dragon 30
Wildcat 5
Will Evans (New 52) 5
Windfall 30
Writer 50
Yasemin Soze 35
|
|
|
Re: Suicide Squad Idol?
|
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666
Wanderer
|
|
OP
Wanderer
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666 |
By the way, how do you change the color of the text for the results?
|
|
|
Re: Suicide Squad Idol?
|
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,188
Legionnaire!
|
|
Legionnaire!
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,188 |
By the way, how do you change the color of the text for the results? If you go to the "Full Screen Reply" one of the buttons (THe "A" with the colours under it) is for Font Colour.
|
|
|
Re: Suicide Squad Idol?
|
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 6,364
Wanderer
|
|
Wanderer
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 6,364 |
Afterthought (New 52)...5
Amanda Waller...5
Amanda Waller (Arrow)...5
Amanda Waller (Film)...5
Amanda Waller (Justice League Unlimited)...5
Amanda Waller (New 52)...5
Atom (Adam Cray)...50
Bane...5
Batman...5
Batman (Rebirth)...5
BattleAxe (New 52)...5
Behemoth (New 52)...5
Big Sir...50
Black Adam...5
Black Manta (New 52)...5
Black Orchid...50
Black Spider (Assault on Arkham)...5
Black Spider (New 52)...5
Blackguard...50
Blackstarr...50
Blockbuster (Mark Desmond)...50
Bolt...5
Briscoe...5
Bronze Tiger...50
Bronze Tiger (Arrow)...5
Bronze Tiger (Rebirth)...5
Cameron Chase...5
Capt. Richard Montgomery Flag...50
Captain Boomerang (Assault on Arkham)...5
Captain Boomerang (Film)...5
Captain Boomerang (George Harkness)...5
Captain Boomerang (Justice League Unlimited)...5
Captain Boomerang (New 52)...5
Captain Boomerang (Owen Mercer)...5
Captain Cold...5
Catalyst...50
Catwoman (Rebirth)...5
Cheetah (New 52)...5
Chemo...50
Chloe Sullivan (Smallville)...5
Chronos...50
Clock King...50
Clock King (Justice League Unlimited)...5
Cluemaster...50
Copperhead...50
Count Vertigo...50
Cupid (Arrow)...5
Deadshot...5
Deadshot (Arrow)...5
Deadshot (Assault on Arkham)...5
Deadshot (Film)...5
Deadshot (Justice League Unlimited)...5
Deadshot (New 52)...5
Deadshot (Smallville)...5
Digger Harkness (Arrow)...5
Doctor Light (Arthur Light)...50
Double Down...50
Dr. Hugh Evans...50
Dr. Moon...50
Dr. Polaris (New 52)...5
Duchess...50
El Diablo (Film)...5
El Diablo (New 52)...5
Electrocutioner...50
Eliza...5
Emerald Empress (Rebirth)...5
Enchantress...50
Enchantress (Film)...5
Enchantress (New 52)...5
Enforcer...50
Firehawk...50
Flex...5
Flo Crowly...5
Golden Eagle II...50
Hack (Rebirth)...5
Harley Quinn (Arrow)...5
Harley Quinn (Assault on Arkham)...5
Harley Quinn (Film)...5
Harley Quinn (New 52)...5
Heatmonger...50
Iceberg (New 52)...5
Icicle (Cameron Mahkent)...50
Icicle (Smallville)...5
Javelin...50
Jess Bright (Koshchei the Deathless)...50
Jewelee...50
Jewelee (Rebirth)...5
John Diggle (Arrow)...5
Johnny Sorrow (Rebirth)...5
Karin Grace...50
Karma (Wayne Hawkins)...50
Katana...50
Katana (Film)...5
Katana (New 52)...5
Killer Croc (Film)...5
Killer Croc (New 52)...5
Killer Frost...50
Killer Frost (Rebirth)...5
King Faraday...50
King Shark...50
King Shark (Arrow)...5
King Shark (Assault on Arkham)...5
King Shark (New 52)...5
Knockout...50
Lady Liberty...50
Larvanaut...50
Lobo (Rebirth)...5
Lyla Diggle /Harbinger(Arrow)...5
Major Disaster...50
Major Victory...50
Manchester Black...5
Manhunter/Privateer (Mark Shaw)...50
Marauder...50
Maser/ Air Wave III...50
Mindboggler...50
Mirror Master (Evan McCulloch)...5
Mr. 104...50
Multi-Man...50
Multiplex...50
Nemesis (Tom Tresser)...50
Nightshade...50
Oracle...5
Outlaw...5
Parasite...5
Penguin...5
Persuader (Cole Parker)...5
Plasmus...50
Plastique...50
Plastique (Justice League Unlimited)...5
Poison Ivy...5
Power Girl...5
Psi...50
Punch...50
Punch (Rebirth)...5
Putty...5
Quartzite...5
Ravan...50
Ravan Nassar (Arrow)...5
Raven (Arrow)...5
Reactron...50
Reverse-Flash (New 52 Daniel West)...5
Richard Rogers Flag (Anthony Miller)...50
Rick Flag (Film)...5
Rick Flag (Rebirth)...5
Rick Flag (Smallville)...5
Rick Flagg (Justice League Unlimited)...5
Rustam (Rebirth)...5
Sam Makoa...50
Savant (New 52)...5
Schrek...5
Sgt. Frank Rock...5
Shade the Changing Man...50
Sheba...5
Shrapnel...50
Shrapnel (Arrow)...5
Shrike...50
Sidearm...50
Silent Majority...50
Silver Swan (Valerie Beaudry)...50
Sledge...5
Slipknot...50
Slipknot (Film)...5
Solomon Grundy...5
Speedy (Roy Harper)...50
Sportsmaster (Victor Gover)...50
Stalnoivolk...5
Star-Spangled Kid (Courtney Whitmore)...5
Steel (John Henry Irons)...5
Superboy (Kon-El)...5
Tattooed Man...50
The General...5
Thermal...5
Thinker (Cliff Carmichael)...5
Thinker (Clifford De Voe)...5
Top...50
Torque (Arrow)...5
Twister...50
Unknown Soldier...5
Ventriloquist (Rebirth)...5
Virtuosa...25
Vixen...50
Volocity...5
Warp (Smallville)...5
Warrant...5
Weasel...50
White Dragon...50
Wildcat...5
Will Evans (New 52)...5
Windfall...50
Writer...50
Yasemin Soze...5
|
|
|
Re: Suicide Squad Idol?
|
Joined: Sep 2013
Posts: 31,847
Tempus Fugitive
|
|
Tempus Fugitive
Joined: Sep 2013
Posts: 31,847 |
Afterthought (New 52)
Amanda Waller 50
Amanda Waller (Arrow) 5
Amanda Waller (Film) 5
Amanda Waller (Justice League Unlimited) 5
Amanda Waller (New 52) 5
Atom (Adam Cray) 50
Bane 5
Batman 5
Batman (Rebirth) 5
BattleAxe (New 52) 5
Behemoth (New 52) 5
Big Sir 10
Black Adam 5
Black Manta (New 52) 15
Black Orchid 50
Black Spider (Assault on Arkham) 5
Black Spider (New 52) 15
Blackguard 5
Blackstarr 5
Blockbuster (Mark Desmond) 50
Bolt 15
Briscoe 50
Bronze Tiger 50
Bronze Tiger (Arrow) 5
Bronze Tiger (Rebirth) 5
Cameron Chase 10
Capt. Richard Montgomery Flag 50
Captain Boomerang (Assault on Arkham) 5
Captain Boomerang (Film) 5
Captain Boomerang (George Harkness) 50
Captain Boomerang (Justice League Unlimited) 5
Captain Boomerang (New 52) 5
Captain Boomerang (Owen Mercer) 5
Captain Cold 40
Catalyst 20
Catwoman (Rebirth) 5
Cheetah (New 52) 5
Chemo 5
Chloe Sullivan (Smallville) 5
Chronos 40
Clock King 10
Clock King (Justice League Unlimited) 5
Cluemaster 10
Copperhead 10
Count Vertigo 50
Cupid (Arrow) 5
Deadshot 50
Deadshot (Arrow) 5
Deadshot (Assault on Arkham) 5
Deadshot (Film) 5
Deadshot (Justice League Unlimited) 5
Deadshot (New 52) 5
Deadshot (Smallville) 5
Digger Harkness (Arrow) 5
Doctor Light (Arthur Light) 50
Double Down 5
Dr. Hugh Evans 50
Dr. Moon 40
Dr. Polaris (New 52) 5
Duchess 40
El Diablo (Film) 5
El Diablo (New 52) 10
Electrocutioner 10
Eliza 5
Emerald Empress (Rebirth) 5
Enchantress 50
Enchantress (Film) 5
Enchantress (New 52) 5
Enforcer 10
Firehawk 5
Flex 5
Flo Crowly 50
Golden Eagle II 5
Hack (Rebirth) 5
Harley Quinn (Arrow) 5
Harley Quinn (Assault on Arkham) 5
Harley Quinn (Film) 5
Harley Quinn (New 52) 5
Heatmonger 5
Iceberg (New 52) 5
Icicle (Cameron Mahkent) 10
Icicle (Smallville) 5
Javelin 50
Jess Bright (Koshchei the Deathless) 50
Jewelee 50
Jewelee (Rebirth) 5
John Diggle (Arrow) 5
Johnny Sorrow (Rebirth) 5
Karin Grace 50
Karma (Wayne Hawkins) 50
Katana 50
Katana (Film) 5
Katana (New 52) 5
Killer Croc (Film)5
Killer Croc (New 52)5
Killer Frost 40
Killer Frost (Rebirth) 5
King Faraday 20
King Shark 30
King Shark (Arrow) 5
King Shark (Assault on Arkham) 5
King Shark (New 52) 5
Knockout 5
Lady Liberty 40
Larvanaut 5
Lobo (Rebirth) 5
Lyla Diggle /Harbinger(Arrow) 5
Major Disaster 10
Major Victory 50
Manchester Black 5
Manhunter/Privateer (Mark Shaw) 50
Marauder 5
Maser/ Air Wave III 5
Mindboggler 50
Mirror Master (Evan McCulloch) 50
Mr. 104 40
Multi-Man 15
Multiplex 40
Nemesis (Tom Tresser) 50
Nightshade 50
Oracle 50
Outlaw 20
Parasite 40
Penguin 50
Persuader (Cole Parker) 5
Plasmus 5
Plastique 50
Plastique (Justice League Unlimited) 5
Poison Ivy 50
Power Girl 5
Psi 50
Punch 50
Punch (Rebirth)5
Putty 5
Quartzite 5
Ravan 50
Ravan Nassar (Arrow) 5
Raven (Arrow) 5
Reactron 10
Reverse-Flash (New 52 Daniel West) 5
Richard Rogers Flag (Anthony Miller)50
Rick Flag (Film) 5
Rick Flag (Rebirth) 5
Rick Flag (Smallville) 5
Rick Flagg (Justice League Unlimited) 5
Rustam (Rebirth) 5
Sam Makoa 5
Savant (New 52) 5
Schrek 5
Sgt. Frank Rock 5
Shade the Changing Man 50
Sheba 50
Shrapnel 20
Shrapnel (Arrow) 5
Shrike 50
Sidearm 5
Silent Majority 50
Silver Swan (Valerie Beaudry) 10
Sledge 5
Slipknot 50
Slipknot (Film) 5
Solomon Grundy 10
Speedy (Roy Harper) 30
Sportsmaster (Victor Gover) 15
Stalnoivolk 30
Star-Spangled Kid (Courtney Whitmore) 5
Steel (John Henry Irons) 5
Superboy (Kon-El) 5
Tattooed Man 20
The General 10
Thermal 5
Thinker (Cliff Carmichael) 50
Thinker (Clifford De Voe) 50
Top 5
Torque (Arrow) 5
Twister 20
Unknown Soldier 5
Ventriloquist (Rebirth) 5
Virtuosa 5
Vixen 50
Volocity 5
Warp (Smallville) 5
Warrant 5
Weasel 50
White Dragon 5
Wildcat 5
Will Evans (New 52) 5
Windfall 10
Writer 50
Yasemin Soze 5
"...not having to believe in a thing to be interested in it and not having to explain a thing to appreciate the wonder of it."
|
|
|
Re: Suicide Squad Idol?
|
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,188
Legionnaire!
|
|
Legionnaire!
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,188 |
Just so there isn't Flag confusion:
Capt. Richard Montgomery Flag - The guy from the WWII Dinosaur island days.
Richard Rogers Flag (Anthony Miller) - The guy from the Brave and the Bold who later went on to lead the 80's Squad, retconned afterwards to have actually been Anthony Miller.
|
|
|
Re: Suicide Squad Idol?
|
Joined: Sep 2013
Posts: 31,847
Tempus Fugitive
|
|
Tempus Fugitive
Joined: Sep 2013
Posts: 31,847 |
Ah, I had wondered. I had no idea about the retcon.
If no one minds, I've gone back and increased my points for Richard Rogers Flag from 5 to 50.
Thanks Dave!
"...not having to believe in a thing to be interested in it and not having to explain a thing to appreciate the wonder of it."
|
|
|
Re: Suicide Squad Idol?
|
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666
Wanderer
|
|
OP
Wanderer
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666 |
Ah, I had wondered. I had no idea about the retcon.
If no one minds, I've gone back and increased my points for Richard Rogers Flag from 5 to 50.
Thanks Dave! I don't mind at all... just updating now
|
|
|
Re: Suicide Squad Idol?
|
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666
Wanderer
|
|
OP
Wanderer
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666 |
By the way, how do you change the color of the text for the results? If you go to the "Full Screen Reply" one of the buttons (THe "A" with the colours under it) is for Font Colour.
|
|
|
Re: Suicide Squad Idol?
|
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666
Wanderer
|
|
OP
Wanderer
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666 |
Ah, I had wondered. I had no idea about the retcon.
If no one minds, I've gone back and increased my points for Richard Rogers Flag from 5 to 50.
Thanks Dave! Hey Is Afterthought getting a 5?
|
|
|
Re: Suicide Squad Idol?
|
Joined: Sep 2013
Posts: 31,847
Tempus Fugitive
|
|
Tempus Fugitive
Joined: Sep 2013
Posts: 31,847 |
I thought it fitting that a character with that name should get his points after the others  5 it is, to join all the others with 5 points, who get custard pies thrown in their faces.
"...not having to believe in a thing to be interested in it and not having to explain a thing to appreciate the wonder of it."
|
|
|
Re: Suicide Squad Idol?
|
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 85,003
Unseen, not unheard
|
|
Unseen, not unheard
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 85,003 |
These are examples of learning curve on an idol ...
Ok I fixed the list
As for the scoring...
I've noticed that we go from 1/0 option to scaled options by around round 3 (because some people will still get 1 vote)
By the scaled option, we end up dumping people who don't get in the top 60% (or whatever line we make) of the vote. The lowest people can get in scaled voting is 5 due to outlier issues in the scoring
Is there another way to get at this? Emily and I have almost completely different scoring systems. Both work well, but have very different mechanics. Emily would be the best person to ask for this.
|
|
|
Re: Suicide Squad Idol?
|
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Legionnaire!
|
|
Legionnaire!
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095 |
I got the idea for the scoring system after Scarecrow was the winner of the first round of the Bat-Villain Idol. I decided to go the academic route, which is why we usually eliminate people under 60% of the vote.
However, it is not a hard rule. I sometimes have bent the criteria for elimination (30 percents in some of the earlier rounds) in order to keep the pool of characters high in the early rounds. I tighten it up as the game progresses, which is why we often switch to a 7 or 10 scale.
Go with the good and you'll be like them; go with the evil and you'll be worse than them.- Portuguese Proverb
|
|
|
Re: Suicide Squad Idol?
|
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666
Wanderer
|
|
OP
Wanderer
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666 |
I got the idea for the scoring system after Scarecrow was the winner of the first round of the Bat-Villain Idol. I decided to go the academic route, which is why we usually eliminate people under 60% of the vote.
However, it is not a hard rule. I sometimes have bent the criteria for elimination (30 percents in some of the earlier rounds) in order to keep the pool of characters high in the early rounds. I tighten it up as the game progresses, which is why we often switch to a 7 or 10 scale. Great... thanks! That's very helpful
|
|
|
Re: Suicide Squad Idol?
|
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666
Wanderer
|
|
OP
Wanderer
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666 |
I thought it fitting that a character with that name should get his points after the others 5 it is, to join all the others with 5 points, who get custard pies thrown in their faces. Afterthought is your... afterthought... Hmmmm I see what you did there
|
|
|
Re: Suicide Squad Idol?
|
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095
Legionnaire!
|
|
Legionnaire!
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 3,095 |
This is hard. I find myself eliminating some characters for too heroic, and others for being too villainous.
Afterthought (New 52) 45
Amanda Waller 50
Amanda Waller (Arrow) 5
Amanda Waller (Film) 25
Amanda Waller (Justice League Unlimited) 30
Amanda Waller (New 52) 50
Atom (Adam Cray) 20
Bane 30
Batman 5
Batman (Rebirth) 5
BattleAxe (New 52) 5
Behemoth (New 52) 40
Big Sir 10
Black Adam 15
Black Manta (New 52) 20
Black Orchid 5
Black Spider (Assault on Arkham) 15
Black Spider (New 52) 30
Blackguard 25
Blackstarr 20
Blockbuster (Mark Desmond) 45
Bolt 20
Briscoe 10
Bronze Tiger 50
Bronze Tiger (Arrow) 25
Bronze Tiger (Rebirth) 50
Cameron Chase 15
Capt. Richard Montgomery Flag 50
Captain Boomerang (Assault on Arkham) 25
Captain Boomerang (Film) 25
Captain Boomerang (George Harkness) 50
Captain Boomerang (Justice League Unlimited) 20
Captain Boomerang (New 52) 50
Captain Boomerang (Owen Mercer) 5
Captain Cold 5
Catalyst 15
Catwoman (Rebirth) 20
Cheetah (New 52) 40
Chemo 5
Chloe Sullivan (Smallville) 25
Chronos 5
Clock King 30
Clock King (Justice League Unlimited) 15
Cluemaster 35
Copperhead 20
Count Vertigo 15
Cupid (Arrow) 5
Deadshot 50
Deadshot (Arrow) 5
Deadshot (Assault on Arkham) 25
Deadshot (Film) 25
Deadshot (Justice League Unlimited) 10
Deadshot (New 52) 50
Deadshot (Smallville) 25
Digger Harkness (Arrow) 5
Doctor Light (Arthur Light) 5
Double Down 25
Dr. Hugh Evans 25
Dr. Moon 30
Dr. Polaris (New 52) 35
Duchess 10
El Diablo (Film) 50
El Diablo (New 52) 25
Electrocutioner 30
Eliza 5
Emerald Empress (Rebirth) 5
Enchantress 45
Enchantress (Film) 50
Enchantress (New 52) 45
Enforcer 10
Firehawk 5
Flex 5
Flo Crowly 5
Golden Eagle II 15
Hack (Rebirth) 25
Harley Quinn (Arrow) 25
Harley Quinn (Assault on Arkham) 30
Harley Quinn (Film) 50
Harley Quinn (New 52) 50
Heatmonger 5
Iceberg (New 52) 30
Icicle (Cameron Mahkent) 40
Icicle (Smallville) 40
Javelin 10
Jess Bright (Koshchei the Deathless) 5
Jewelee 10
Jewelee (Rebirth) 20
John Diggle (Arrow) 25
Johnny Sorrow (Rebirth) 5
Karin Grace 5
Karma (Wayne Hawkins) 15
Katana 50
Katana (Film) 40
Katana (New 52) 45
Killer Croc (Film) 50
Killer Croc (New 52) 50
Killer Frost 50
Killer Frost (Rebirth) 40
King Faraday 10
King Shark 5
King Shark (Arrow) 5
King Shark (Assault on Arkham) 5
King Shark (New 52) 5
Knockout 50
Lady Liberty 15
Larvanaut 5
Lobo (Rebirth) 40
Lyla Diggle /Harbinger(Arrow) 5
Major Disaster 5
Major Victory 15
Manchester Black 50
Manhunter/Privateer (Mark Shaw) 30
Marauder 20
Maser/ Air Wave III 15
Mindboggler 30
Mirror Master (Evan McCulloch) 25
Mr. 104 30
Multi-Man 30
Multiplex 20
Nemesis (Tom Tresser) 50
Nightshade 40
Oracle 50
Outlaw 5
Parasite 5
Penguin 20
Persuader (Cole Parker) 15
Plasmus 50
Plastique 50
Plastique (Justice League Unlimited) 25
Poison Ivy 40
Power Girl 5
Psi 5
Punch 15
Punch (Rebirth) 30
Putty 5
Quartzite 40
Ravan 5
Ravan Nassar (Arrow) 5
Raven (Arrow) 5
Reactron 15
Reverse-Flash (New 52 Daniel West) 5
Richard Rogers Flag (Anthony Miller) 50
Rick Flag (Film) 40
Rick Flag (Rebirth) 40
Rick Flag (Smallville) 40
Rick Flagg (Justice League Unlimited) 15
Rustam (Rebirth) 15
Sam Makoa 25
Savant (New 52) 20
Schrek 5
Sgt. Frank Rock 50
Shade the Changing Man 30
Sheba 15
Shrapnel 30
Shrapnel (Arrow) 15
Shrike 5
Sidearm 5
Silent Majority 15
Silver Swan (Valerie Beaudry) 50
Sledge 15
Slipknot 35
Slipknot (Film) 25
Solomon Grundy 5
Speedy (Roy Harper) 25
Sportsmaster (Victor Gover) 5
Stalnoivolk 25
Star-Spangled Kid (Courtney Whitmore) 30
Steel (John Henry Irons) 30
Superboy (Kon-El) 30
Tattooed Man 20
The General 5
Thermal 25
Thinker (Cliff Carmichael) 5
Thinker (Clifford De Voe) 5
Top 5
Torque (Arrow) 15
Twister 15
Unknown Soldier 5
Ventriloquist (Rebirth) 35
Virtuosa 50
Vixen 25
Volocity 5
Warp (Smallville) 50
Warrant 5
Weasel 5
White Dragon 15
Wildcat 5
Will Evans (New 52) 5
Windfall 15
Writer 15
Yasemin Soze 15
Go with the good and you'll be like them; go with the evil and you'll be worse than them.- Portuguese Proverb
|
|
|
Re: Suicide Squad Idol?
|
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666
Wanderer
|
|
OP
Wanderer
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666 |
Closing out round 3 today...
|
|
|
Re: Suicide Squad Idol?
|
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666
Wanderer
|
|
OP
Wanderer
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 9,666 |
Ok there may be some challenges here as I figure out the percentages (hee hee)
Here's the ranked list:
Bronze Tiger 250
Mindboggler 230
Nightshade 230
Richard Rogers Flag (Anthony Miller) 230
Enchantress 225
Nemesis (Tom Tresser) 225
Manhunter/Privateer (Mark Shaw) 220
Plastique 220
Vixen 215
Katana 210
Shade the Changing Man 210
Slipknot 210
Amanda Waller 205
Captain Boomerang (George Harkness) 205
Count Vertigo 205
Deadshot 205
Atom (Adam Cray) 200
Blockbuster (Mark Desmond) 200
Dr. Hugh Evans 200
Psi 200
Duchess 190
Jewelee 190
Mr. 104 190
Ravan 190
Black Orchid 185
Jess Bright (Koshchei the Deathless) 185
Speedy (Roy Harper) 185
Karin Grace 180
Punch 180
Doctor Light (Arthur Light) 175
Killer Frost 175
Multiplex 175
Oracle 175
Shrike 175
Javelin 170
Writer 170
Chronos 165
Dr. Moon 165
Weasel 165
Poison Ivy 160
Knockout 155
Major Victory 155
Silent Majority 155
Catalyst 150
Lady Liberty 150
Sheba 150
Silver Swan (Valerie Beaudry) 150
Thinker (Cliff Carmichael) 145
Briscoe 140
Mirror Master (Evan McCulloch) 140
Stalnoivolk 140
Virtuosa 140
Icicle (Cameron Mahkent) 135
Karma (Wayne Hawkins) 135
King Shark 135
Thinker (Clifford De Voe) 135
Bronze Tiger (Rebirth) 130
Deadshot (New 52) 130
El Diablo (Film) 130
Maser/ Air Wave III 130
Penguin 130
Flo Crowly 125
Multi-Man 125
Tattooed Man 125
Capt. Richard Montgomery Flag 120
Captain Boomerang (New 52) 120
Captain Cold 120
Cluemaster 120
Harley Quinn (Film) 120
Harley Quinn (New 52) 120
Killer Croc (New 52) 120
King Faraday 120
Plasmus 120
Twister 120
Manchester Black 115
Sam Makoa 115
Shrapnel 115
White Dragon 115
Windfall 115
Chemo 110
Amanda Waller (New 52) 105
Clock King 105
El Diablo (New 52) 105
Electrocutioner 105
Enchantress (New 52) 105
Amanda Waller (Justice League Unlimited) 100
Copperhead 100
Enchantress (Film) 100
Katana (Film) 100
Katana (New 52) 100
Killer Croc (Film) 100
Parasite 100
Rick Flag (Rebirth) 100
Big Sir 95
Captain Boomerang (Justice League Unlimited) 95
Double Down 95
Sidearm 95
Sportsmaster (Victor Gover) 95
Blackguard 90
Enforcer 90
Firehawk 90
Major Disaster 90
Amanda Waller (Film) 85
Blackstarr 85
Captain Boomerang (Owen Mercer) 85
Deadshot (Film) 85
Deadshot (Justice League Unlimited) 85
Golden Eagle II 85
Hack (Rebirth) 85
Killer Frost (Rebirth) 85
Marauder 85
Outlaw 85
Reactron 85
Superboy (Kon-El) 85
Yasemin Soze 85
Captain Boomerang (Film) 80
Plastique (Justice League Unlimited) 80
Punch (Rebirth) 80
Rick Flag (Film) 80
Black Adam 75
Black Spider (New 52) 75
Bolt 75
Catwoman (Rebirth) 75
Cheetah (New 52) 75
Jewelee (Rebirth) 75
Rick Flagg (Justice League Unlimited) 75
Sgt. Frank Rock 75
Top 75
Ventriloquist (Rebirth) 75
Dr. Polaris (New 52) 70
Heatmonger 70
Icicle (Smallville) 70
Larvanaut 70
Warp (Smallville) 70
Afterthought (New 52) 65
Bane 65
Batman 65
Black Manta (New 52) 65
Cameron Chase 65
Emerald Empress (Rebirth) 65
Lobo (Rebirth) 65
The General 65
Behemoth (New 52) 60
Harley Quinn (Assault on Arkham) 60
John Diggle (Arrow) 60
King Shark (New 52) 60
Quartzite 60
Rick Flag (Smallville) 60
Deadshot (Assault on Arkham) 55
King Shark (Arrow) 55
Schrek 55
Solomon Grundy 55
Clock King (Justice League Unlimited) 50
Iceberg (New 52) 50
Slipknot (Film) 50
Star-Spangled Kid (Courtney Whitmore) 50
Steel (John Henry Irons) 50
Batman (Rebirth) 45
Bronze Tiger (Arrow) 45
Captain Boomerang (Assault on Arkham) 45
Chloe Sullivan (Smallville) 45
Deadshot (Arrow) 45
Deadshot (Smallville) 45
Harley Quinn (Arrow) 45
Rustam (Rebirth) 45
Thermal 45
Digger Harkness (Arrow) 40
Johnny Sorrow (Rebirth) 40
Power Girl 40
Savant (New 52) 40
Black Spider (Assault on Arkham) 35
King Shark (Assault on Arkham) 35
Persuader (Cole Parker) 35
Shrapnel (Arrow) 35
Sledge 35
Torque (Arrow) 35
Amanda Waller (Arrow) 30
Lyla Diggle /Harbinger(Arrow) 30
BattleAxe (New 52) 25
Cupid (Arrow) 25
Eliza 25
Flex 25
Putty 25
Ravan Nassar (Arrow) 25
Raven (Arrow) 25
Reverse-Flash (New 52 Daniel West) 25
Unknown Soldier 25
Volocity 25
Warrant 25
Wildcat 25
Will Evans (New 52) 25
|
|
|
|
Forums14
Topics21,066
Posts1,050,292
Legionnaires1,731
| |
Most Online53,886
Jan 7th, 2024
|
|
|
Posts: 119
Joined: February 2009
|
|
|
|
