Roll Call
0 Legionnaires (), 68 Murran Spies, and 9 Spider Guild Agents.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Time-Scope
Wonder Woman
by Ann Hebistand - 05/24/25 04:31 AM
The Non-Legion Comics Trivia Thread Pt 5
by Invisible Brainiac - 05/24/25 02:50 AM
Legion Trivia 6
by Invisible Brainiac - 05/24/25 02:50 AM
My Art Commissions (Legion or Not Legion it's art)
by Invisible Brainiac - 05/24/25 02:50 AM
Recent Legion-verse sightings in DCU proper
by colonyofcells - 05/23/25 11:35 PM
Bits Of (Random) Legionnaire Business...
by Korbal - 05/23/25 09:07 PM
Omnicom
Previous Thread
Next Thread
Print Thread
Page 21 of 27 1 2 19 20 21 22 23 26 27
Joined: Jul 2003
Posts: 40,911
Trap Timer
Trap Timer
Joined: Jul 2003
Posts: 40,911
Quote
Originally posted by Nightcrawler:
The prices are going up, I bet their expectations are getting lower and lower on what they consider acceptable sales.
Another way of looking at it:

v6 #1-- 44415 x $4 = $177,660
v5 #1-- 59944 x $3 = $179,982

Joined: Apr 2010
Posts: 520
K
Active
Active
K Offline
Joined: Apr 2010
Posts: 520
Quote
Originally posted by googoomuck:
I would guess that DC wasn't expecting LSH #1 to do all that great, otherwise they would have printed more copies. Some of the other DC numbers were downright depressing.
Compared to other DC titles only, LSH V6#1 is ranked #16 in the DC titles.

Shooter's first issue (issue 37, sales for December 2007) was ranked #21 among DC titles only.

The first Supergirl issue (issue 16, sales for March 2006) was ranked #16 among DC only. The ranking doesn't take reorders into consideration. Using reorders and assuming nothing else has reorders that affect the listing, it would be #34 overall and #13 among DC.

V5#1 was #10 among DC only.

Joined: Apr 2010
Posts: 520
K
Active
Active
K Offline
Joined: Apr 2010
Posts: 520
Quote
Originally posted by Eryk Davis Ester:
Another way of looking at it:

v6 #1-- 44415 x $4 = $177,660
v5 #1-- 59944 x $3 = $179,982
You forgot inflation, so we have:

v6 #1-- 44415 x $4 = $177,660
v5 #1-- 59944 x $3 = $204,117 (in 2010 dollars)

Joined: Sep 2003
Posts: 34,634
Bold Flavors
Bold Flavors
Joined: Sep 2003
Posts: 34,634
One thing to consider is that in all of Paul's interviews he's mentioned he realizes the Legion has not been a top-seller for 20+ years and so he knows its his job to make it that way. One can only hope his intentions--of building sales over time--can come to fruition. Probably Green Lantern is the only DC title/franchise to do that in the last 10 years.

All we know is that the #1 has the Legion right back where we were before. That's not too surprising. How many #1 issues and relaunches can you release in 15 years? "Fool me once, shame on me" and all that.

If #1 sold out and had the second printing, one can hope DC will print more the second issue. Hopefully that sells out too. And then by #6 release the Legion flight ring to give a faux sales bump.

Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,188
Legionnaire!
Legionnaire!
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,188
May Numbers are in and as others have mentioned Legion of Super-Heroes #1 comes in at a solid, but not setting the world on fire, 44K. The question is, where does it go from here?

05/2010: Legion of Super-Heroes #1 -- 44,415, #39 out of 300


Adventure meanwhile takes a hit after the end of the crossover (though really, this issue ties up a lot of loose ends from not only the Crossover but the whole Robinson run with the characters). Paul Levitz now has a 34K launchpad to work with for the secondary title.

08/2009: Adventure Comics #1 -- 56,706, #30 out of 300
09/2009: Adventure Comics #2 -- 47,296, #44 out of 300
10/2009: Adventure Comics #3 -- 44,431 #40 out of 300
11/2009: Adventure Comics #4 -- 85,145 #6 out of 300
12/2009: Adventure Comics #5 -- 59,876 #21 out of 300 *
01/2010: Adventure Comics #6 -- 42,514 #33 out of 300 *
02/2010: Adventure Comics #7 -- 53,721 #23 out of 300 *
03/2101: Adventure Comics #8 -- 39,351 #39 out of 300
03/2010: Adventure Comics #9 -- 37,515 #44 out of 300
04/2010: Adventure Comics #10 -- 37,573 #41 out of 300
05/2010: Adventure Comics #11 -- 34,794 #54 out of 300

(* denotes no Legion content)

Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,188
Legionnaire!
Legionnaire!
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,188
Anecdotally, when I got to my shop last night, #2 had sold out and they only had a couple of the #1 reprints left.

Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,188
Legionnaire!
Legionnaire!
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,188
Diamond released their top 100 for June. It will be a while for the ICV2 estimates, but LSH came in at #43 (37.33% of Batman) and Adventure came in at #55 (33.09% of Batman). The tricky bit is that Batman is an anniversary issue this month (#700) and therefore it's harder to estimate sales on the fly.

Looking at the issues around it (JSA, Deadpool, Ultimate Sipdey), it looks like LSH #2 remained pretty consistent, remarkable for a second issue. I'd ballpark it a little above 40K.

Joined: Apr 2010
Posts: 520
K
Active
Active
K Offline
Joined: Apr 2010
Posts: 520
That doesn't mean it stayed consistent, since we don't know the *actual* sales for #1 including reorders. I wouldn't be surprised if it's just as sharp a decline as a #2 usually gets.

Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,188
Legionnaire!
Legionnaire!
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,188
June numbers are in and as a nice surprise LSH #1 recharts this month adding another 5,691 copies sold, putting #1 over 50K. #2 comes in just under 40K, which isn't a bad drop off considering first month sales (higher obviously when the additional orders are included). It will be interesting to see if there's re-order activity on #2.

05/2010: Legion of Super-Heroes #1 -- 44,415, #39 out of 300 [50,106]
06/2010: Legion of Super-Heroes #2 -- 39,102, #43 out of 300

Adventure, meanwhile, stays pretty much where it was, shedding about 100 readers from the previous team. The question becomes what will be the retention level here? Atom back-ups also start soon, so Brightest Day branding may impact future sales as well.

08/2009: Adventure Comics #1 -- 56,706, #30 out of 300
09/2009: Adventure Comics #2 -- 47,296, #44 out of 300
10/2009: Adventure Comics #3 -- 44,431 #40 out of 300
11/2009: Adventure Comics #4 -- 85,145 #6 out of 300
12/2009: Adventure Comics #5 -- 59,876 #21 out of 300 *
01/2010: Adventure Comics #6 -- 42,514 #33 out of 300 *
02/2010: Adventure Comics #7 -- 53,721 #23 out of 300 *
03/2101: Adventure Comics #8 -- 39,351 #39 out of 300
03/2010: Adventure Comics #9 -- 37,515 #44 out of 300
04/2010: Adventure Comics #10 -- 37,573 #41 out of 300
05/2010: Adventure Comics #11 -- 34,794 #54 out of 300
06/2010: Adventure Comics #12 -- 34,663 #55 out of 300

(* denotes no Legion content)

Joined: Apr 2010
Posts: 520
K
Active
Active
K Offline
Joined: Apr 2010
Posts: 520
LSH V5#1: 59944
LSH V5#2: 48584
Drop: 18.9%

LSH V5#16(Supergirl and the Legion): 54826
LSH V5#17: 47697
Drop: 13.0%

LSH V5#37 (Shooter run starts): 45803
LSH V5#38: 33045
Drop: 27.9%

Legion of Three Worlds #1: 68306
Legion of Three Worlds #2: 64412
Drop: 5.7%

Adventure #1: 56706
Adventure #2: 47296
Drop: 16.6%

LSH V6#1: 50106
LSH V6#2: 39102
Drop: 22.0%

Definitely not a small drop, although reorders for #2 could change this. And it's still less than the first V5 and the first Supergirl (though it now beats the first Shooter).

Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,188
Legionnaire!
Legionnaire!
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,188
Diamond has released thier top 100 for July and LSH charts at #45 (@48 % of Batman #701) while Adventure charts at #63 (40.4 % of Batman). The top 300 and ICV2's estimates are later in the month, so the sepculation for now is how much did Batman move in July?

Educated guesses so far put Legion at around 37K and Adventure closer to 32K.

Joined: Aug 2007
Posts: 741
Active
Active
Joined: Aug 2007
Posts: 741
Has anyone any idea what sales levels will be needed for DC to not mess with/cancel the LSH or Adventure titles?


"Our devotion to each other was unexplainable"
"You were kids"
"No Batman, we were Legion"
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,188
Legionnaire!
Legionnaire!
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,188
In the DCU (Wildstorm & Vertigo have different criterea), books have plummeted to the low teens and sometimes lower before getting the axe. Of course, there are other factors as well. For example, different creative teams presumably have different page rates which affect how profitable a book is.

Joined: Apr 2010
Posts: 520
K
Active
Active
K Offline
Joined: Apr 2010
Posts: 520
Shooter's run ended at about 22000, and must have been cancelled while it was higher than that--#46 is almost 25000 and beats most of the reboot post-1997. (And at that point it was already feeling the effects of having the retroboot start to come out at the same time.)

I don't know if that actually would be sufficient to cancel most books or if it's just DC internal politics.

It's odd that V6 looks better by ranking than by numbers. #1 (with reorders) would be #31. #2 is 43 and #3 is 45. By numbers all three issues are doing considerably worse than the first three Supergirl/LSH, but by rankings they're all better than Supergirl/LSH. V5 #1-3 is still better than them, however.

Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 29,461
Time Trapper
Time Trapper
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 29,461
Quote
Originally posted by Ken Arromdee:
It's odd that V6 looks better by ranking than by numbers. #1 (with reorders) would be #31. #2 is 43 and #3 is 45. By numbers all three issues are doing considerably worse than the first three Supergirl/LSH, but by rankings they're all better than Supergirl/LSH. V5 #1-3 is still better than them, however.
don't forget the economy in general. comics are more likely to be trimmed in tight times than food, gas or any number of necessities. less overall comics sales = a smaller overall pie; similar %s before and during equate to lower numbers.


The childhood friend Exnihil never had.
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,188
Legionnaire!
Legionnaire!
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,188
Chart placement in general isn't a great indicator of success as any given month Marvel or DC flood the market with one-shots, events, tie-ins, etc. so 43rd one month could easily have been 33rd the next.

As to the sales level, the bar is definitely getting lower, as the Red Cirlce books were down to almost 10K before cancellation and REBELS and Doom Patrol aren't that far from that point now. As I said a few posts above, economics may be different for different books, but where LSH and Adventure both have "newer" artists, I think there's a lot of rope left.

Joined: Apr 2010
Posts: 520
K
Active
Active
K Offline
Joined: Apr 2010
Posts: 520
If the bar is that low, then why did the Threeboot get cancelled? It didn't sell that poorly at all by these standards, it started higher than V6, and the first Supergirl issue again started higher than V6. And it beat the reboot handily. It ended low, but only after the retroboot cannibalized its sales, and it still didn't end at as low as 10000.

Joined: Jul 2003
Posts: 4,322
L
Legionnaire!
Legionnaire!
L Offline
Joined: Jul 2003
Posts: 4,322
Don't forget, sell-through(% of initial monthly orders sold) is important too. That's a big reason why some lower selling titles aren't cancelled, as explained to me by my CBS' owner.

Joined: Aug 2007
Posts: 741
Active
Active
Joined: Aug 2007
Posts: 741
Quote
Originally posted by lil'rhino:
Don't forget, sell-through(% of initial monthly orders sold) is important too. That's a big reason why some lower selling titles aren't cancelled, as explained to me by my CBS' owner.
Sorry for sounding dumb lil'rhino but can you explain this a little more please.

thanks


"Our devotion to each other was unexplainable"
"You were kids"
"No Batman, we were Legion"
Joined: May 2008
Posts: 851
Active
Active
Joined: May 2008
Posts: 851
Quote
Originally posted by Ken Arromdee:
If the bar is that low, then why did the Threeboot get cancelled? It didn't sell that poorly at all by these standards, it started higher than V6, and the first Supergirl issue again started higher than V6. And it beat the reboot handily. It ended low, but only after the retroboot cannibalized its sales, and it still didn't end at as low as 10000.
You basically answered that: retroboot killed it.

Joined: Jul 2003
Posts: 9,916
Wanderer
Wanderer
Joined: Jul 2003
Posts: 9,916
rhino refers to the amount of books that a title actually sells through at the store is higher for the lower ordered books than the others.

Meaning the CBS owner is not sitting with a ton of product on the shelves for these (lesser produced) titles as the hardcore fans eat them up quickly, but he has to buy extra Batman, Superman, Spider-Man, etc. titles for the walls and bins for the casual and the occasional cross-promotion buyers.

So ordering a few issues of R.E.B.E.L.S. is just instant profit and the popular titles are both short-term and long-term profit (if they ever push them out the door for cover price). The popular titles are more of a risk long-term.

Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,188
Legionnaire!
Legionnaire!
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,188
But because comics (mostly) aren't returnable to the distributor, Diamond (and ultimately DC and Marvel), don't really care about or track sell-through. Their numbers reflect what they sell to their clients: the stores in the Direct Market.

What those stores do with the books (sell them, leave them on the shelf, mark them up, mark them down, etc.), is largely irrelevant to them. Presumably stores course correct by adjusting their orders over time ('Wow, no one's buying Mega Crossover tie-in #82. I'd better order 20 copies less of #85 or I'll eat them'), and those numbers are important to publishers, but the bottom line in analyzing these numbers are what the stores buy in bulk from Diamond.

There's been talk for years about how cool a point-of-sale system would be to track what people are really buying, but there's really no benefit to the Publishers or distributor to do this if the model remains as is.

Joined: Apr 2010
Posts: 520
K
Active
Active
K Offline
Joined: Apr 2010
Posts: 520
Sales are now out, and are pretty much as expected. No reorders though. 39102 to 36360 is a 7% decline. It is below #8 of the threeboot, and below the #7 Supergirl issue. It is still above all of the reboot from 1997-onwards and still above all except #1 of the Shooter issues.

Joined: Apr 2010
Posts: 520
K
Active
Active
K Offline
Joined: Apr 2010
Posts: 520
The sales figures posted many pages earlier in this thread don't quite go back as far as possible. Diamond started being the exclusive distributor as of September 1996, so we can add 7 more months to that list (from www.chron.com).

Legionnaires #42 - 25391
Legion of Super-Heroes #86 - 33130
Legionnaires #43 - 27299
Legion of Super-Heroes #87 - 27789
Legionnaires #44 - 26169
Legion of Super-Heroes #88 - 28864
Legionnaires #45 - 25835
Legion of Super-Heroes #89 - 27495
Legionnaires #46 - 25693
Legion of Super-Heroes #90 - 27286
Legionnaires #47 - 25489
Legion of Super-Heroes #91 - 26961
Legionnaires #48 - 25547
Legion of Super-Heroes #92 - 26696

I haven't been able to find any Capital City sales information on the web (I guess you can't find everything on the Internet).

Later figures are still at this link for the reboot and this link for the threeboot .

V6 #3 still beats all these figures.

Omnicom did a graph, but the last time they did it was in the Shooter run, which is here. They also did a graph for the entire lifetime of the Legion which can be found here but unfortunately there is no presentation of the 1994-1996 sales as numbers so it's really hard to tell how well the reboot did.

Joined: Aug 2007
Posts: 741
Active
Active
Joined: Aug 2007
Posts: 741
Quote
Originally posted by Nightcrawler:
rhino refers to the amount of books that a title actually sells through at the store is higher for the lower ordered books than the others.

Meaning the CBS owner is not sitting with a ton of product on the shelves for these (lesser produced) titles as the hardcore fans eat them up quickly, but he has to buy extra Batman, Superman, Spider-Man, etc. titles for the walls and bins for the casual and the occasional cross-promotion buyers.

So ordering a few issues of R.E.B.E.L.S. is just instant profit and the popular titles are both short-term and long-term profit (if they ever push them out the door for cover price). The popular titles are more of a risk long-term.
Thanks Nightcrawler. I understand that now but don't see why stores making more money stops DC cancelling it?


"Our devotion to each other was unexplainable"
"You were kids"
"No Batman, we were Legion"
Page 21 of 27 1 2 19 20 21 22 23 26 27

Link Copied to Clipboard
Hyperpath Console
Comment Guidelines: Do post respectful and insightful comments. Don't flame, hate, spam.
Sarcasm Kid: Am I gonna see anyone at NYCC this Thursday?
Nightcrawler: Staying local, sorry.
Fat Cramer: Hello Legion World. Missed you! Lots of catching up to do.
Gaseous Lad: Welcome back FC!!!! We missed you!
Ann Hebistand: Cramey! hug love
thoth lad: Great to see you Cramer!
Kappa Kid: Hope everyone is doing well! smile
Eryk Davis Ester: Wow! Cramer and Kappa Kid? Are we gathering up all fo the members for some big #200 anniversary event or something? wink
Invisible Brainiac: sweet! nice seeing ya, FC and Kappa!
Future: Hi, Legion World! Thanks for keeping the Legion alive!
Ann Hebistand: Hi! Good to see you here. I miss your comments on the Transformers G1 cartoon.
Eryk Davis Ester: Now Future? Wow!
Reboot: Truly, there was a future, once.
Sarcasm Kid: Happy Hanksgiving all you turkey droppings
Ann Hebistand: LOL. Belated Happy Thanksgiving to you, Sarky dear.
Sarcasm Kid: Candle is alive she's okay
Eryk Davis Ester: Santa brought thoth back!
Ann Hebistand: Huzzah!
Rockhopper Lad: The Rookery Holiday party is in progress! Pop by!
Ann Hebistand: I am so going to attend! Thanks, Rocky!
Nightcrawler: Updated us to version 8.0 of the software. Everything resets to the default settings. I'll be restoring things back to normal as I have time.
Nightcrawler: Sorry. Didn't realize the solution I had for the old PHP would screw up the new board.
Reboot: Wait, Version 8 actually happened shocked
Nightcrawler: Yeah. smile
Reboot: *insert "It Has Been 84 Years" clip here*
Invisible Brainiac: thanks Nighty, appreciate it smile
Ann Hebistand: Yes! Thank you, Nightcrawler. And Happy New Year, Legion Worlders! CalorieQueen
Rockhopper Lad: Howdy, Legion Worlders! love
Ann Hebistand: Hi, Rocky! hug love
thoth lad: Rocky!
Lard Lad: Yo, Adrian!
Ann Hebistand: "Gonna fly now"
cleome58: "I'm the Queen of 58 and I'm here to state..." wink
Nightcrawler: Our server got moved by our host, so any images that were uploaded today will need to be reuploaded and replaced. Sorry. I think I fixed it now.
Eryk Davis Ester: Have you embraced the new Legion revival yet?
Ann Hebistand: Beggars can't be choosers. smile
Ann Hebistand: Seriously, I'll support it no matter what.
Invisible Brainiac: I'm giving it a quick, light, welcoming pat-on-the-back hug, until I get to know it better smile
Lard Lad: There's no real info yet, right? Just some teases from Waid?
Ann Hebistand: The current EiC, Marie Javins, also said the Legion is coming back.
Gaseous Lad: Oh I had not heard that comment.
Ann Hebistand: Legion Idol 2025 is active in the Spaceopoly forum! Join the fun!
Invisible Brainiac: thank you, Annfie, so kind of you!
Ann Hebistand: Superman issue 28 has Darkseid's Legion. Scheduled for July. CalorieQueen
Forum Statistics
Forums14
Topics21,119
Posts1,053,866
Legionnaires1,733
Most Online53,886
Jan 7th, 2024
Newest Legionnaires
Dick Grayson's PTSD, Joe, Boy Kid Lad, Anonymous Girl, Mimi
1,733 Registered Legionniares
Today's Birthdays
There are no members with birthdays on this day.
Random Holo-Vids
Member Spotlight
The Red Bee
The Red Bee
Indiana
Posts: 242
Joined: March 2004
Powered by UBB.threads™ PHP Forum Software 8.0.0