Roll Call
1 Legionnaires (stile86, stile86, stile86, stile86), 33 Murran Spies, and 11 Spider Guild Agents.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Time-Scope
The Non-Legion Comics Trivia Thread Pt 5
by stile86 - 05/03/25 03:19 AM
I'm Thinking of a DCU character Part 6!
by stile86 - 05/03/25 03:05 AM
RIP Butch Guice
by stile86 - 05/03/25 03:03 AM
Bits Of (Random) Legionnaire Business...
by Korbal - 05/02/25 09:25 PM
Mon-El's Adventures In The Phantom Zone!
by Korbal - 05/02/25 12:57 PM
Legion Tryout Idol 2025! (discussion on the list)
by Invisible Brainiac - 05/02/25 03:20 AM
Omnicom
Previous Thread
Next Thread
Print Thread
Joined: Aug 2003
Posts: 394
Active
Active
Joined: Aug 2003
Posts: 394
Super Sacrifice of the Legionnaires: what the hell? confused

Is it just me or was this the most messed up story ever published in the silver age of comic books?

I like Garth and all but I'm pretty sure, if I was a legionnaire, I wouldn't get me and my friends together for some mass cult suicide to bring him back.

The writer was probably trying to make some sort of message about how, even though such characters as M'onel are much more powerful than Garth, his nobility in sacrificing himself for others made him the most essenital legionnaire. What the hell kinda message is that to send to little children: some people's lives are worth more than others?

No wonder Lightning Lad made such a lousy leader. I imagine his whole term went something like this:

Garth: Gee Sun Boy. That was a pretty lousy job you did on that mission. Way to go accidently wiping out the people of Corvan IV. You're expelled from the team.

Dirk: Gee Garth. Remember that time I was prepared to get electrocuted to death so that your lifeless corpse could be re-animated?

Garth: Uh...come to think of it, I never like the Corvan IV's anyway with those weird dots on their face and all. As you were Star Boy.

Joined: Jul 2003
Posts: 33,081
Time Trapper
Time Trapper
Joined: Jul 2003
Posts: 33,081
Yeah, it was pretty weird at that.


Visit the FULL FRONTAL FANDANGO & laugh along with Lash at http://lashlaugh.wordpress.com/
Joined: Jul 2003
Posts: 33,081
Time Trapper
Time Trapper
Joined: Jul 2003
Posts: 33,081
And kinda a slap in the face to later dead Legionnaires.

I mean, you didn't see everyone falling all over themselves trying to revive Chemical King or Invisible Kid.


Visit the FULL FRONTAL FANDANGO & laugh along with Lash at http://lashlaugh.wordpress.com/
Joined: Jul 2003
Posts: 40,897
Trap Timer
Trap Timer
Joined: Jul 2003
Posts: 40,897
It is kind of weird that, once you have a method for reviving the dead, it only gets used on some. Apparently Mon-El was important enough to be revived.

Joined: Aug 2003
Posts: 394
Active
Active
Joined: Aug 2003
Posts: 394
And kinda a slap in the face to poor Proty I whose tiny little statue looks pretty ordinary compared with those 50 foot Ferro statues that they had everywhere towards the end of the Adventure era run.

Joined: Aug 2003
Posts: 394
Active
Active
Joined: Aug 2003
Posts: 394
Hmm...come to think of it, Garth and Mon-El were the only characters that had "clean" deaths. All the others were fried (Ferro, Luornu, Karate Kid) crushed (Lyle) etc. so maybe it wouldn't have worked on them.

Still...the writer's really should have known better. That scene where they are all silently hoping that it was they who were struck down by the lightning was beyond insane.

Joined: Jul 2003
Posts: 24,141
Not much between despair and ecstacy
Not much between despair and ecstacy
Joined: Jul 2003
Posts: 24,141
Actually, I don't think it's the "most" messed-up story ever published. The Legion's second appearance, "Prisoner of the Super-Heroes" (ADVENTURE # 267) was even worse.

But you're right, Shadow Kid. If you examine this story (or even most of the Silver Age Legion stories) too logically, it doesn't hold up. I don't remember the specifics, but it always bugged me that Saturn Girl was lured away and impersonated. She's a telepath. It should be next to impossible to surprise her.

(Yes, I know she does not use her powers to pry into the affairs of others, but considering the setting -- a lightning-bombarded jungle world where anything can happen -- and the circumstances -- one of the Legionnaires was going to die -- I'd think she'd have a little extra caution to make sure the scheme went as planned.)


Check out my new Power Club website!

The Semi-Great Gildersleeve - writing, super-heroes, and this 'n' that
Joined: Jul 2003
Posts: 40,897
Trap Timer
Trap Timer
Joined: Jul 2003
Posts: 40,897
Well, to be fair she was surprised by another telepath.

And I don't think the basic idea of the story, that the only way the dead Legionnaire could be brought back was through the sacrifice of another member, and that they would all volunteer to use a random process to choose which one it would be, was all that bad. The actual image of them standing around holding lightning rods is pretty absurd, however.

Joined: Aug 2003
Posts: 394
Active
Active
Joined: Aug 2003
Posts: 394
I find it interesting that in both stories involving Garth's death, Imra tries to sacrifice herself and as a result gets someone else killed.

Poor Proty. frown If only Imra had learnt her lesson the first time around.

Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 101
Substitute
Substitute
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 101
ElementLad I would imagine in WnK's coming utopic 31st c., cloning would be an easy way to extend life (if the body hasn't suffered irreparable brain damage). Perhaps the Legionnaires are rebelling against this by letting their members die as heroes, in battle! Perhaps not. ElementLad


Link Copied to Clipboard
Hyperpath Console
Comment Guidelines: Do post respectful and insightful comments. Don't flame, hate, spam.
Sarcasm Kid: Am I gonna see anyone at NYCC this Thursday?
Nightcrawler: Staying local, sorry.
Fat Cramer: Hello Legion World. Missed you! Lots of catching up to do.
Gaseous Lad: Welcome back FC!!!! We missed you!
Ann Hebistand: Cramey! hug love
thoth lad: Great to see you Cramer!
Kappa Kid: Hope everyone is doing well! smile
Eryk Davis Ester: Wow! Cramer and Kappa Kid? Are we gathering up all fo the members for some big #200 anniversary event or something? wink
Invisible Brainiac: sweet! nice seeing ya, FC and Kappa!
Future: Hi, Legion World! Thanks for keeping the Legion alive!
Ann Hebistand: Hi! Good to see you here. I miss your comments on the Transformers G1 cartoon.
Eryk Davis Ester: Now Future? Wow!
Reboot: Truly, there was a future, once.
Sarcasm Kid: Happy Hanksgiving all you turkey droppings
Ann Hebistand: LOL. Belated Happy Thanksgiving to you, Sarky dear.
Sarcasm Kid: Candle is alive she's okay
Eryk Davis Ester: Santa brought thoth back!
Ann Hebistand: Huzzah!
Rockhopper Lad: The Rookery Holiday party is in progress! Pop by!
Ann Hebistand: I am so going to attend! Thanks, Rocky!
Nightcrawler: Updated us to version 8.0 of the software. Everything resets to the default settings. I'll be restoring things back to normal as I have time.
Nightcrawler: Sorry. Didn't realize the solution I had for the old PHP would screw up the new board.
Reboot: Wait, Version 8 actually happened shocked
Nightcrawler: Yeah. smile
Reboot: *insert "It Has Been 84 Years" clip here*
Invisible Brainiac: thanks Nighty, appreciate it smile
Ann Hebistand: Yes! Thank you, Nightcrawler. And Happy New Year, Legion Worlders! CalorieQueen
Rockhopper Lad: Howdy, Legion Worlders! love
Ann Hebistand: Hi, Rocky! hug love
thoth lad: Rocky!
Lard Lad: Yo, Adrian!
Ann Hebistand: "Gonna fly now"
cleome58: "I'm the Queen of 58 and I'm here to state..." wink
Nightcrawler: Our server got moved by our host, so any images that were uploaded today will need to be reuploaded and replaced. Sorry. I think I fixed it now.
Eryk Davis Ester: Have you embraced the new Legion revival yet?
Ann Hebistand: Beggars can't be choosers. smile
Ann Hebistand: Seriously, I'll support it no matter what.
Invisible Brainiac: I'm giving it a quick, light, welcoming pat-on-the-back hug, until I get to know it better smile
Lard Lad: There's no real info yet, right? Just some teases from Waid?
Ann Hebistand: The current EiC, Marie Javins, also said the Legion is coming back.
Gaseous Lad: Oh I had not heard that comment.
Ann Hebistand: Legion Idol 2025 is active in the Spaceopoly forum! Join the fun!
Invisible Brainiac: thank you, Annfie, so kind of you!
Ann Hebistand: Superman issue 28 has Darkseid's Legion. Scheduled for July. CalorieQueen
Forum Statistics
Forums14
Topics21,114
Posts1,053,519
Legionnaires1,732
Most Online53,886
Jan 7th, 2024
Newest Legionnaires
Joe, Boy Kid Lad, Anonymous Girl, Mimi, max kord
1,732 Registered Legionniares
Today's Birthdays
LegionFan223
Random Holo-Vids
Member Spotlight
The Red Bee
The Red Bee
Indiana
Posts: 242
Joined: March 2004
ShanghallaLegion of Super-Heroes & all related proper names & images are ™ & © material of DC Comics, Inc. & are used herein without its permission.
This site is intended solely to celebrate & publicize these characters & their creators.
No commercial benefit, nor any use beyond the “fair use” review & commentary provisions of United States copyright law, is either intended or implied.
Posts made on this message board must not be reproduced without the author's consent.
The Legion World Star
Powered by UBB.threads™ PHP Forum Software 8.0.0