Legion World Forums LEGION CLUBHOUSE The Legion of Super-Heroes LSH cover FACEOFF!!!

so tough, i'll go with Baxter cause it's crisper and Sensor Girl is the most prominent.

they're both awesome though.

Baxter for me.

Baxter.

Tales has too much filler.

I'll take the lean yet satisfying BAXTER.

Tales, because it shows more characters.

Variations on the same idea without much to distinguish either. I'll go with Baxter because it's cleaner.

Never seen the Tales version before. I'll go with it, because it's new, it has more characters, and it's a bit more misleading, with Energy Boy or whatever front and center.

That very strange looking alien in the bubble (below/behind Power Boy's leg), all slug-like with many eyes, intrigues me.

Both covers have 'Tiger Girl' and the floating fish! Woot!

Both are gorgeous. Lightle rules.

I was tempted by the "more characters" factor at first, but then I realized that most of the additional characters are Legionnaires, and there's only about two additional applicants on the Tales cover.

Baxter by a nose. Sensor Girl looks really impressive.

Baxter

yeah i did too but, isn't the perspective weird. like she's giant sized as dev-em and comet queen are under her cape. yet she's bigger than them both.

Baxter, easily. Never liked the Tales because it made me think Cham, Mon, Wildfire are re-applying for the Legion or all the applicants are official members of Legion? nah.


Baxter s better.

At first I was like 'this is a really tough one', but the more I look at them, the Baxter one is definitely better.

Crisper and cleaner as someone else said. I also had never noticed until now that all the background characters on the Tales cover are already Legionnaires - which is a bit boring.

But the main factor that makes the Baxter cover better for me - the blurb!

Who Will Be the 5 New Members of the LSH?

I love covers that give me a mystery! And if I hadn't already known which 5 characters there made it in before I got around to reading that issue I probably would have spent about an hour formulating a guess before I turned the first page.

(For the record, I probably would have guessed - Tiger Girl, Dev Em, Sensor Girl, Comet Queen and Magnetic Kid.)

Baxter, for me.

Baxter. The other is too busy.

Baxter, easily.

Tales.

I'm on the fence with this one because both are really good covers .... but I must finally cast my vote for Tales because, as someone else has said above, there are more characters on the cover.

Baxter

Andthe original runs away with this one as well.

Baxter = 13

Tales = 5

One more, then I'll mix some things up...

Man, that's tough! The background is more interesting on the Baxter cover, but you can see how Lightle's style on characters has become more refined on Tales.

Hm. I think I will go with the Baxter cover because it's just more striking and memorable. More detail. Excellent logo incorporation. A hint of the adversaries and setting. Nice use of purple and red.

This time I'll go with Tales, even though the text in the lower right-hand corner detracts from the effect.

Baxter.