posted
It's been far too long (at least from what I've researched scrolling through this forum) since we've done a Legion Survivor game. Those were my favorite back when I was a more active poster. I don't mean to step on Kid Prime or Invisible Brainiac's toes by running one, but I think it's about time again, don't you?
One thing I found fascinating about Eryk's 'Favorite Legionnaire' poll is how much I second guessed my votes thanks to there being a third version of certain Legionnaires now. Couple that with all the Three Worlds hype and it got me thinking: we'll soon learn who the favorite Legionnaire is from EDE's poll, but which reality are they from? I recall Lu and Mon tend to win things like this, but which version? Who will be the last threebooter standing? Postbooter? Who would make an Exiles-like 25 member Legion team? Let's find out!
I've listed below established Legionnaires from the three main realities. Some Legionnaires have two or three versions listed, some only one. There are no honoraries/reserves/false pretenses, as well as no versions of Legionnaires who were not members in their reality (such as postboot Tenzil or threeboot Mon). I decided against separate entries for SW6 & TMK Legions, but not the members exclusive to those teams. 111 Legionnaires should be enough.
Let's shoot for doing roughly one round per day. For this first round, vote for your 15 LEAST FAVORITE Legionnaire Versions, and we'll eliminate 10 tomorrow.
Andromeda (Postboot) Apparition (Postboot) Blok (Preboot) Bloodclaw (TMK Preboot) Bouncing Boy (Preboot) Brainiac 5 (Preboot) Brainiac 5 (Postboot) Brainiac 5 (Threeboot) Catspaw (Preboot) Chameleon (Postboot) Chameleon (Threeboot) Chameleon Boy (Preboot) Chameleon Girl (Preboot) Chemical King (Preboot) Chuck Taine (Postboot) Colossal Boy (Preboot) Colossal Boy (Threeboot) Computo (Preboot) Cosmic Boy (Preboot) Cosmic Boy (Postboot) Cosmic Boy (Threeboot) Dawnstar (Preboot) Dragonmage (Preboot) Dream Boy (Threeboot) Dream Girl (Preboot) Dream Girl (Threeboot) Dreamer (Postboot) Element Lad (Preboot) Element Lad (Postboot) Element Lad (Threeboot) Ferro Lad (Preboot) Ferro (Postboot) Firefist (TMK Preboot) Flederweb (TMK Preboot) Gates (Postboot) Gear (Postboot) Impulse/Kent Shakespeare (TMK Preboot) Invisible Kid I (Preboot) Invisible Kid II (Preboot) Invisible Kid (Postboot) Invisible Kid (Threeboot) Karate Kid (Preboot) Karate Kid (Postboot) Karate Kid (Threeboot) Kid Quantum (Preboot) Kid Quantum (Postboot) Kid Quantum II (Postboot) Kinetix (Postboot) Kono (TMK Preboot) Laurel Gand (TMK Preboot) Leviathan (Postboot) Light Lass/Lightning Lass (Preboot) Light Lass (Threeboot) Lightning Lad (Preboot) Lightning Lad (Threeboot) Live Wire (Postboot) Magnetic Kid (Preboot) Magno (Postboot) Matter-Eater Lad (Preboot) Mon-El (Preboot) M'Onel (Postboot) Monstress (Postboot) Nemesis Kid (Preboot) Neon/Celeste Rockfish (TMK Preboot) Night Girl (Preboot) Phantom Girl (Preboot) Phantom Girl (Threeboot) Polar Boy (Preboot) Projectra/Sensor Girl (Preboot) Projectra (Threeboot) Quislet (Preboot) Reflecto II/Devlin O'Ryan (TMK Preboot) Saturn Girl (Preboot) Saturn Girl (Postboot) Saturn Girl (Threeboot) Sensor (Postboot) Shadow Lass (Preboot) Shadow Lass (Threeboot) Shikari (Postboot) Shrinking Violet (Preboot) Shrinking Violet/Leviathan (Postboot) Shrinking Violet/Atom Girl (Threeboot) Spark (Postboot) Spider-Girl (Preboot) Star Boy (Preboot) Star Boy (Postboot) Star Boy (Threeboot) Sun Boy (Preboot) Sun Boy (Threeboot) Superboy (Preboot) Superboy (Kon; Postboot) Supergirl (Preboot) Supergirl (Threeboot) Tellus (Preboot) Thunder (Postboot) Timber Wolf (Preboot) Timber Wolf (Postboot) Timber Wolf (Threeboot) Triad (Postboot) Triplicate Girl/Duo Damsel (Preboot) Triplicate Girl (Threeboot) Tyroc (Preboot) Ultra Boy (Preboot) Ultra Boy (Postboot) Ultra Boy (Threeboot) Umbra (Postboot) Veilmist (Preboot) White Witch (Preboot) Wildfire (Preboot) Wildfire (Postboot) XS (Postboot)
posted
what? no Nemesis Kid? no SUBS members such as Chlor/ Dag? Infectious Lass? Color Kid? They were part of TMK era, so should be counted on the list! Gossmar, Alchemist, Inferno are missing from the list, as well (you have Apparition, Umbra and Leviathan on the list).
From: Hayward, CA | Registered: Jul 2003
| IP: Logged |
Eryk Davis Ester
Created from the Cosmic Legends of the Universe!
posted
Bloodclaw Chameleon Girl Dawnstar Dream Boy Element Lad (Postboot) Ferro Firefist Karate Kid (Preboot) Karate Kid (Postboot) Karate Kid (Threeboot) Kid Quantum II Monstress Sensor Star Boy (Preboot) Supergirl (Threeboot)
NOTE: Star Boy is on the list to register my dislike of Johns version of the character, rather than anything actually depicted preboot.
From: Liberty City | Registered: Jul 2003
| IP: Logged |
posted
Superboy, those SW6 codenames present are the postboot versions. I hesitate to count the SW6ers since some of them are rather redundant to their preboot or postboot counterparts. But if people want the SW6ers, I can add them. I just thought the list would get too long.
I certainly have no problem adding Nemesis Kid though, and the arguement for some of the SUBS is good, as Drura did come back for a bit FYL. I'm just not sure how many to include of the Gap members. Visi-Lad? Reflecto? Atmos?
Registered: Jul 2003
| IP: Logged |
Eryk Davis Ester
Created from the Cosmic Legends of the Universe!
posted
I'd say there's enough differences between the TMK versions of characters and pre-TMK versions of characters that I'd like to see that acknowledged in some way. I would suggest adding in the "SW6" versions, where it's understood that a vote for that version is a vote for TMK's portrayal of the character more generally.
From: Liberty City | Registered: Jul 2003
| IP: Logged |
posted
I just may do this from the comments so far. EDE, I'm assuming that means adding BOTH SW6 and TMK versions and not one version to represent both, right? Just want to make sure I'm reading it right.
What does everyone else think? I'm fine with letting people edit their votes too by the way, as we sort things out.
Registered: Jul 2003
| IP: Logged |
Set
There's not a word yet, for old friends who've just met.
posted
I'm completely unqualified for this. 'My' preboot Legion has Mon-El in it, and the only Laurel is Laurel Kent, so I have no idea what this preboot Legion is!
Registered: Aug 2006
| IP: Logged |
posted
I'd say that, if you add an extra roster or two, the number of picks in the first few rounds will have to go up.
But I thought the point of this was to tie-in to "Legion of Three Worlds" - i.e., based on Johns' versions, the postbootalike version, and the "threeboot" version. Adding extra rosters confuses that.
-------------------- My views are my own and do not reflect those of everyone else... and I wouldn't have it any other way.
posted
That was my logic for sure by exluding different preboot versions, Reboot. Going with what would be in Threeworlds. I admit sympathy on my part by adding in the TMK-exclusive Legionnaires, though it looks like I set myself up for disaster there.
Registered: Jul 2003
| IP: Logged |
posted
I'd suggest that you should just draw a line, and say "it's started now, too late to change it", rather than fiddling after voting's started (whether or not people can edit). If you start adding in extras, what about people who want the 'toon LSH added?!
quote:Originally posted by Future: I decided against different entries for the SW6 Legionnaires and the TMK Legion. 109 Legionnaires should be enough.
-------------------- My views are my own and do not reflect those of everyone else... and I wouldn't have it any other way.
posted
Brainiac 5 (Threeboot) Chuck Taine (Postboot) Colossal Boy (Threeboot) Cosmic Boy (Threeboot) Dream Boy Kinetix Magno M'Onel Monstress Saturn Girl (Threeboot) Sensor Star Boy (Threeboot) Superboy (Kon; Postboot) Supergirl (Threeboot) Wildfire (Postboot)
-------------------- I tried to rip their soul out.I tried to make them forget Superman. But they won't.
From: Kentucky | Registered: Oct 2005
| IP: Logged |
Hyperpath: Email this page to someone!
Printer-friendly view of this topic | Subscribe To Topic
![[Smile]](smile.gif)
